The Teaser Wins the Debate
Lure vs. bait on Stellwagen in early April — Rob brought the clams, Mike brought the Jig Biki rig. By the end of the first drift, the fish had made the call.
Stellwagen Bank, early April. First film trip of 2022 — and one long-running debate settled before lunch.
Every April the lure-vs-bait debate comes back around on Stellwagen. Capt. Rob Lowell brought the clams. I brought the Jig Biki rig, baitless, and a high degree of confidence that the teasers would do the work. With Jeff Forten along for the ride, we drifted the southeast corner in about 130 feet of flat-calm water and let the fish decide. Ten to twelve haddock in the box from the first drift. Every single one on the teasers — not the jig body.
This was the first film trip of the season. Flat-calm morning, Stellwagen Bank, the kind of early-April day that rewards showing up. Here’s how the system read it.
What the calendar and the bank told us before we left the dock
Context that shapes every decision that follows.
Early April on Stellwagen is the opening of the Cape Cod offshore season. Haddock are resident on the bank year-round — they don’t migrate the way striped bass do. What changes in April is access: the weather breaks, the regulations kick in, and the fish are findable on the southeast corner in the 120–150 foot depth band. Rob had been producing fish at 130 feet the previous week. That’s the starting depth.
- 130 ft was the productive depth the week prior. Start there and adjust based on what the sounder shows — bait marks tight to the bottom, not suspended mid-column.
- Before April 15: one cod per person. The presentation has to minimize foul hooks on short cod schooled in with the haddock. Slow and close to bottom — not a fast aggressive retrieve.
- Drift resets matter as much as the drift itself. 1,000–1,500 foot passes, circle wide on the reset, use the chartplotter to replicate the productive track.
- Etiquette: Stellwagen in April is busy. Give boats room. Don’t run through another drift. Everybody can find their own patch — the haddock are spread, not stacked in one spot.
What the conditions confirmed on arrival
Does the environment support what the historical read predicted?
Flat calm, early April. Light current at the start of the session — enough to carry a clean drift, light enough that a 6.5oz jig holds near-vertical contact at 130 feet without fighting to stay down. Cold water temperatures are normal for this time of year; what drives haddock activity is current, not temperature. As the tide started to move through the session, the bite picked up accordingly.
What the first drift confirmed
Four layers. Each one narrows the answer further.
“All the fish today are coming on the teasers — not the jig body. The Biki teasers quiver naturally in the current while the jig anchors them near the bottom. That’s the system doing the work.”
No surface activity. Bait confirmed on the sounder — marks tight to the bottom in 130 feet alongside haddock returns. Small redfish and forage also visible in the zone. Eliminated all surface presentations. Bait is on the deck, fish are on the deck. Vertical presentation only, bottom contact required on every drop.
Consistent biting through the first drift. 10–12 haddock in the box from one pass. All fish mouth-caught. Every single bite came on the Biki teasers — not the jig body. Debate settled. Confirmed: the teasers are the primary attractor. The jig anchors the system at depth and provides a larger profile below — but the quivering teaser is what the fish commit to.
Flat gravel/sand bottom at 130 ft. Fish holding tight to the substrate, not suspended. Current building slightly as the session progressed — bite improved with moving water. Confirmed: rig needs to be close to the deck. Not aggressively worked through the column — quiver on the bottom, let the teasers do the work in the current.
Bait marks tight to bottom confirmed on arrival. Mid-session: a dense pile of returns appeared on the sounder. Circled wide, positioned uptide, dropped right into it. Produced immediately. Sonar is the primary navigation tool on Stellwagen. When the screen shows a notable pile, circle wide, get uptide, and drop into it. Don’t drive through the mark.
Running the drift — and the reset
The approach is as much about the reset as the drift itself.
Drift jigging on Stellwagen doesn’t require complex positioning. The bank is open, the drift direction is set by wind and current, and the job is to cover productive water systematically. What takes judgment is the reset: how to get back uptide without disrupting other boats, without running over your own drift zone, and without blowing through a pile the sounder just showed you.
“I usually try to stick with a thousand to fifteen hundred foot drift at the most and keep them dialed in that way. Every time you make a pass, the bait kind of stays in the area and almost chums up the next fish.”
Approach — step by step
Drift track over the productive zone. Reset wide, replicate the track. When the sounder shows a pile mid-reset, circle uptide and drop into it.
The system that settled the debate
Not just a jig. A system. And the fish voted.
The Hogy Jig Biki Rig is a high-low teaser system with a snap at the bottom that accepts a jig or sinker. Clip on a Sand Eel Jig and you have two attractors working at once: the jig body below as weight and profile anchor, and the Biki teasers above quivering naturally in any current. You can tip the teasers with bait or fish them clean. On this day, clean outperformed bait — and every fish came on the teasers.
- Jig Biki Rig ties directly to leader via the top crane swivel. Simple clinch knot.
- Sand Eel Jig clips onto the dual-lock snap at the bottom — no knot, easy weight swaps.
- Fish clean or tip teasers with bait (clams, squid). Clean outproduced bait on this trip.
- 60lb braid + fluorocarbon top shot (~12 ft). Gets down fast, maintains feel at depth.
Outfit
The Twitch Jig retrieve — step by step
Twitch Jig retrieve — short twitches from the rod butt, rig stays near the deck. The Biki teasers quiver while the Sand Eel Jig anchors the system at depth.
“I’m not out-fishing the bait — I’m catching just as many fish, making less of a mess. I don’t feel like I’m at a disadvantage. And all my fish are mouth-caught. None foul-hooked.”
The decision at a glance
Cod stocks in the Gulf of Maine are in active rebuilding. The slow Twitch Jig presentation with teasers is specifically designed to minimize foul hooks on short cod schooled with the haddock. Every fish on this trip was mouth-caught. Measure every fish, release shorts immediately in good condition, and confirm current NOAA and Massachusetts DMF regulations before keeping any groundfish. A soft rod and a slow retrieve are the right tools for responsible early-season groundfishing.
Step 1 set the context: early April Stellwagen, haddock resident on the SE corner, tight cod regulations requiring a slow conservative presentation. Step 2 confirmed flat-calm drifting conditions. Step 3 locked in the answer: all bites on the Biki teasers — not the jig body. The teasers quivering naturally in the current were the actual attractor; the Sand Eel Jig was the anchor. Step 4 built the drift plan: search-and-find, 1,500 foot passes, wide resets, sonar primary. Step 5 executed: Jig Biki Rig on a 6.5” Sand Eel Jig, Twitch Jig retrieve, near-zero speed, close to the deck. Ten to twelve haddock in the box from the first drift, all mouth-caught, no bait required. Debate settled.
Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.